Skip to main content

Comparing OSPF with distance vector routing protocols

Comparing OSPF with distance vector routing protocols
2.2.3 This page will explain how OSPF compares to distance vector protocols such as RIP. Link-state routers maintain a common picture of the network and exchange link information upon initial discovery or network changes. Link-state routers do not broadcast routing tables periodically as distance vector protocols do. Therefore, link-state routers use less bandwidth for routing table maintenance.
RIP is appropriate for small networks, and the best path is based on the lowest number of hops. OSPF is appropriate for large, scalable internetworks, and the best path is determined by the speed of the link. RIP and other distance vector protocols use simple algorithms to compute best paths. The SPF algorithm is complex. Routers that implement distance vector protocols need less memory and less powerful processors than those that implement OSPF.
OSPF selects routes based on cost, which is related to speed. The higher the speed, the lower the OSPF cost of the link.
OSPF selects the fastest loop-free path from the SPF tree as the best path in the network.
OSPF guarantees loop-free routing. Distance vector protocols may cause routing loops.
If links are unstable, flooding of link-state information can lead to unsynchronized link-state advertisements and inconsistent decisions among routers.
OSPF addresses the following issues:
  • Speed of convergence
  • Support for Variable Length Subnet Mask (VLSM)
  • Network size
  • Path selection
  • Grouping of members
In large networks RIP convergence can take several minutes since the routing table of each router is copied and shared with directly connected routers. After initial OSPF convergence, maintaining a converged state is faster because only the changes in the network are flooded to other routers in an area.
OSPF supports VLSMs and therefore is referred to as a classless protocol. RIP v1 does not support VLSMs, however, RIP v2 does support VLSMs.
RIP considers a network that is more than 15 routers away to be unreachable because the number of hops is limited to 15. This limits RIP to small topologies. OSPF has no size limits and is suitable for intermediate to large networks.
RIP selects a path to a network by adding one to the hop count reported by a neighbor. It compares the hop counts to a destination and selects the path with the smallest distance or hops. This algorithm is simple and does not require a powerful router or a lot of memory. RIP does not take into account the available bandwidth in best path determination.
OSPF selects a path using cost, a metric based on bandwidth. All OSPF routers must obtain complete information about the networks of every router to calculate the shortest path. This is a complex algorithm. Therefore, OSPF requires more powerful routers and more memory than RIP.
RIP uses a flat topology. Routers in a RIP region exchange information with all routers. OSPF uses the concept of areas. A network can be subdivided into groups of routers. In this way OSPF can limit traffic to these areas. Changes in one area do not affect performance in other areas. This hierarchical approach allows a network to scale efficiently.
The Interactive Media Activity will help students learn the differences between link-state and distance vector protocols.
The next page will discuss the shortest path algorithm

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

OSI layers / Peer-to-peer communications / TCP/IP model

OSI layers 2.3.4 This page discusses the seven layers of the OSI model. The OSI reference model is a framework that is used to understand how information travels throughout a network. The OSI reference model explains how packets travel through the various layers to another device on a network, even if the sender and destination have different types of network media. In the OSI reference model, there are seven numbered layers, each of which illustrates a particular network function. - Dividing the network into seven layers provides the following advantages: • It breaks network communication into smaller, more manageable parts. • It standardizes network components to allow multiple vendor development and support. • It allows different types of network hardware and software to communicate with each other. • It prevents changes in one layer from affecting other layers. • It divides network communication into smaller parts to make learning it easier to understand. In the foll...
Post a Comment
Read more

PC Basic...

• Backplane – A backplane is an electronic circuit board containing circuitry and sockets into which additional electronic devices on other circuit boards or cards can be plugged; in a computer, generally synonymous with or part of the motherboard. • Network interface card (NIC) – An expansion board inserted into a computer so that the computer can be connected to a network. • Video card – A board that plugs into a PC to give it display capabilities. • Audio card – An expansion board that enables a computer to manipulate and output sounds. • Parallel port – An interface capable of transferring more than one bit simultaneously that is used to connect external devices such as printers. • Serial port – An interface that can be used for serial communication in which only one bit is transmitted at a time. • Mouse port – A port used to connect a mouse to a PC. • USB port – A Universal Serial Bus connector. A USB port connects devices such as a mouse or printer to the computer ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Windowing

Windowing 11.1.5 This page will explain how windows are used to transmit data. Data packets must be delivered to the recipient in the same order in which they were transmitted to have a reliable, connection-oriented data transfer. The protocol fails if any data packets are lost, damaged, duplicated, or received in a different order. An easy solution is to have a recipient acknowledge the receipt of each packet before the next packet is sent. If a sender had to wait for an ACK after each packet was sent, throughput would be low. Therefore, most connection-oriented, reliable protocols allow multiple packets to be sent before an ACK is received. The time interval after the sender transmits a data packet and before the sender processes any ACKs is used to transmit more data. The number of data packets the sender can transmit before it receives an ACK is known as the window size, or window. TCP uses expectational ACKs. This means that the ACK number refers to the next packet that is...
Post a Comment
Read more